Ti-SnO2-Lead Dioxide Anode


The layer of Doped Tin Oxide is applied by painting on a fixed ratio solution of Tin and dopant compounds that are thermally decomposed into the Oxides. A layer of Alpha Lead Dioxide is plated next using an alkali Lead salt bath or perhaps a Lead Nitrate bath at a high current density. Next and lastly a Beta layer of Lead Dioxide is plated on top using a Lead Nitrate plating bath. The Alpha layer has better adherent properties that the Beta. It is also smoother and levels better. The Beta is better for exposure to the (Per)Chlorate electrolyte.
The substrate can be a drilled flat sheet of Ti. Mesh should be OK. Another possible alternative is to obtain a quantity of Ti welding rods. They can be got from you local welding supplier as a special order or as a sample. You can then 'weave' the rods together to form a mesh with, say, 0.5 cm square holes, he mesh being the size of the anode you want. You can weave more/less dense as you think fit. The Ti that is horizontal will play no part in taking current to the anode, it all being done by the vertical rods.
The Ti must be surface treated before any coatings are applied by degreasing, etching and (if possible) sandblasting.
Note:
Titanium does not permit films to be prepared at higher temperatures that 500C because the interface undergoes a sort of swelling and the over-layer becomes fragile and scales.
From J. Applied Electrochem 4 (1974) 57

It should be noted that certain Tin and Antimony compounds are toxic. This is especially true if you attempt to make your own compounds from Tin and Antimony metals + acids.

Some useful symbols
ElementSymbol Atomic weight
TitaniumTi204.4
TinSn118.69
AntimonySb121.75
OxygenO16
ChlorineCl35.45
Some useful formula
NameNameFormulaMolecular Weight% actual Metal
Stannic Chloride Tin(IV) Chloride SnCl4260.5 45.5% Sn
Stannic Chloride Pentahydrate Tin(IV) Chloride SnCl4:5H2O350.533.9% Sn
Stannous Chloride Tin(II) ChlorideSnCl2 189.5962.6% Sn
Stannous Chloride DihydrateTin(II)ChlorideSnCl2:2H2O 225.652.6% Sn
Tin Oxide Tin(IV) OxideSnO2 150.778.76% Sn
Antimony Trichloride Antimony(III) ChlorideSbCl3 228.153.4% Sb
Antimony Trioxide Antimony(III) Oxide Sb2O3291.583.5% Sb

The picture below shows an anode made with a drilled 1mm thick Ti substrate. The small depressions on the
surface give an indication of the spacing of the holes which were 2.5mm diameter. The anode measures 5 cm by 30 cm.

[Ti Substrate LD Anode]

(In relation to the anode)
The process that I finally settled upon is a bit laborious but I have had pretty consistent results:
I used Ti sheet of about 1mm thickness because that is what I had at the time. A little thicker would probably be better.
The first step involves drilling the solid sheet full of small holes. I used a piece of perforated stainless as a drilling guide/pattern. The holes then need to be de-burred or slightly countersunk to get rid of the ragged edges left by the drilling step; I just used a larger diameter drill bit to do this.
The substrate should then be sandblasted, (to help the PbO2 adhere to it. The holes are needed for the same reason) degreased with dish-washing soap, thoroughly rinsed in clean water and dried.
Next, a semiconducting coat of Sb doped SnO2 was applied by painting on a solution of SnCl4 + SbCl3 in water + Butanol, drying, and then heating to 500 degrees Celsius or so in an oxidizing atmosphere i.e. air. This step was repeated five to ten times to give a suitable coating thickness.
Then a thin (about 0.1mm) layer of alpha PbO2 was plated onto the substrate from an alkaline lead tartrate bath.
The final coat of beta PbO2 was then plated over top of this from a lead nitrate bath. This layer was about 2mm thick.

The anode performed well in a perchlorate cell.
The anode above was only used for two batches of perchlorate, starting from NaClO3, which means that it has seen about 200 hours of use at a current of 35-40 A. It still looks pretty much exactly the same. I have made other anodes (using the same process) that I've used in chlorate cells for hundreds of hours with no visible signs of wear.
The alpha PbO2 layer was added in order to improve adhesion + uniformity of the final beta PbO2 layer. See US5683567 for a description of a very similar anode. I used to always try and cut corners but after accumulating a whole lot of hazardous waste from failed attempts I've come to realize that it is easier to do it properly, even if it is more work.
I chose the SnO2/Sb2O3 system because it is easy to apply and the raw materials are easy to come by and above all cheap. SnO2 also has a higher oxygen overvoltage than PbO2 which supposedly means that any exposed SnO2 will not interfere with the anodic formation of Perchlorate.

Some Patents that are relevant to the Ti substrate LD Anode are:
United States Patent 4040939 Tin + Antimony Oxides on Ti + Lead Dioxide.
United States Patent 5683567 Tin metal layer converted to conductive Tin Oxide Layer + Lead Dioxide.
United States Patent 5545306 Uses a Lead metal layer on top of Ti. This Lead Layer is oxidized to Alpha then plated with Beta in a Lead Nitrate bath.
United States Patent 3627669 SnO2 + Sb2O3 coated electrode for brine electrolysis.

GB Patent 850,380 Massive anode using Ta as the plating substrate. See also JES February 1958 in further reading section for similar scheme.


Detailed description of making and using a Titanium/ATO/Lead Dioxide Anode


Making Antimony Trichloride
Making Stannic Chloride

Test for DTO coating

The vast majority of examples in the patents use SnCl4:5H2O and Antimony Trichloride in the DTO precursor solution. SnCl4:5H2O is not readily available.
US Patent 4,208,450 list other compounds which may be used.
The compounds that may be employed include any inorganic or organic salt or ester of tin and the antimony dopant which are thermally decomposable to their respective oxide forms, including their alkoxides, alkoxy halides, amines, and chlorides. Typical salts include: antimony pentachloride, antimony trichloride, dibutyl tin dichloride, stannic chloride and tin tetraethoxide. Suitable solvents include: amyl alcohol, benzene, butyl alcohol, ethyl alcohol, pentyl alcohol, propyl alcohol, toluene and other organic solvents as well as some inorganic solvents such as water.
Theses compounds may/may not work.

Solvents tried for making DTO solution precursor were Methanol, Ethanol, IsoProply Alcohol and also a mixture of water and Methanol. It would appear that the solvent used is not critical. Too much water may cause the Antimony Trichloride to Oxidize and precipitate. The patents usually use Butanol (Butyl Alcohol).

Attempts were made to form a DTO coating using SnCl2:2H2O (Tin(ii) Chloride, Stannous Chloride, or Tin Mordant) via pyrolysis. Little success was had, with the DTO coating failing from zero to 30 minutes after being placed in a test cell.
An attempt was make to convert SnCl2:2H2O to SnCl4 in solution. Stannous Chloride was dissolved in Methanol with some HCl. H2O2 was then very slowly added with cooling to increase the oxidation state of the Stannous to Stannic Chloride. When the Antimony Trichloride was added it immediately oxidized. If the Antimony Trichloride was added first it then oxidized when the H2O2 was added. This avenue was not explored further. If it worked it would be useful as all ingredients are easily available. If low Sb content is used it may help.
US Pat 3713884 uses SnCl2 to obtain an ATO coating on glass via a very exacting procedure.
US Pat 4873352 & 4924017 use Tin Oxalates to obtain an ATO coating. Tin Oxalates are not very easy to obtain.
An ATO coating is outlined in, Desalination 115 (1998) 295-302, using a Sol-Gel procedure using SnCl2. It is somewhat complicated.
ATO coatings using the Oxidative-soak procedure is outlined in, JOURNAL OF MATERIALS SCIENCE LETTERS 22, 2003, 1359 – 1361 & 21, 2002, 1241 – 1243. These coating may be suitable for anodes though an attempt to put ATO onto Co Oxide failed as the SnCl2 reacted with the Cobalt Oxide. It would probably be OK on Ti but the coatings are very thin.

Etching Titanium

Drilling Titanium


HIT THE BACK BUTTON ON YOU BROWSER